Look. We knew From Season 4 was going to be unhinged. However, none of us — and I mean none of us — were prepared for a literal hand to claw its way out of Abby’s grave and try to drag Sheriff Boyd into the dirt with it.
Episode 3, “Merrily We Go,” was dropped on MGM+ on Sunday night, and the closing seconds have already broken Reddit. So, with that in mind, let’s get into it. What does that grave hand actually mean? Are we doing zombies now? Premonitions? Furthermore, is Abby officially in her ghost-girl-villain era?
Pour something. Let’s go.
“Merrily We Go”: What Actually Happened in Episode 3
The episode opens on a double funeral — one for Jim Matthews, and one for the pastor everyone thought was Sophia’s father. To start with, the entire town shows up. However, the proceedings are interrupted almost immediately when a murder of crows descends and lands on the bodies, because of course they do. As Julie correctly clocks in the moment, those birds didn’t show up to grieve. They showed up to gloat.
That sets the tone. In fact, every quiet moment in “Merrily We Go” gets interrupted by something nasty. Here are the major beats:
- Sophia is already poisoning the well. Specifically, she’s needling Julie, asking to move in with Sara, and casually pumping Kenny for intel about when things in town “got worse.” In short, she is fully a tiny psyop, and so far nobody has clocked it.
- Boyd is grief-quietly losing it. Notably, he’s mostly off-screen this episode, working a side project: Acosta — currently in town-jail for trying to escape — is being asked to dig through the storage shed full of dead townspeople’s belongings, in the hope that she’ll spot patterns nobody else has. On top of that, he admits she reminds him of Abby. Yikes.
- Acosta is cracking. Mentally. Moreover, in ways that look exactly like what Abby went through before Boyd had to put her down. The parallel, frankly, is being drawn in highlighter.
- Tabitha and Henry hit the Bottle Tree in the hope of finding a way back to the lighthouse. Instead, they’re met by the Boy in White — except he’s noticeably older now. Furthermore, Tabitha is warned that the rules have changed: “You’re getting so close now, but I’m afraid you’re running out of time.” Cool. Love that for us.
- Ethan sneaks back to the RV to grab the broken radio he believes can let him talk to Thomas. Out in the woods, however, he runs into Jim. Or “Jim.” Either way, he’s told to find the Lake of Tears. New mystery, unlocked.
- Jade has found mushrooms and is meditating. As a result, his reincarnation theory is fully back on the table — and honestly? At this point, I trust him.
- Victor wandered into the forest and stumbled across a yellow suit lying on the ground. Consequently, the trauma response was so bad that he wet himself. In other words, Victor knows the Man in Yellow is real, present, and possibly already in town. The kicker, though: he doesn’t know it’s Sophia.
And then, finally, the ending.
That Hand at Abby’s Grave: Let’s Talk About It
Boyd, alone, sits down at his late wife Abby’s grave. He starts talking. Moreover, he admits he’s tired. He admits he’s thought about ending it. As a matter of fact, he’s at the lowest we’ve seen him since season 1.
Then, out of nowhere, a hand bursts up through the dirt. Bony, fast, furious. Boyd is grabbed by it, and an attempt is made to pull him into the ground.
However, he fights it off. The episode cuts to black.
So. What was that?
Theory 1: It’s Abby. Genuinely. From Beyond.
The most obvious reading, of course: that’s Abby’s hand, and the town has finally figured out that the way to break Sheriff Boyd is to use the woman he had to shoot. After all, From has consistently shown that the dead don’t really leave this place — Tian-Chen, Father Khatri, Thomas, and now possibly Jim. Instead of moving on, they just change form. Therefore, Abby joining that roster makes a horrible amount of sense.
If this is real-Abby, however, the question becomes: is she trying to take him, or warn him? In a town this twisted, my money’s on take.
Theory 2: The Town Is Trying to Suicide-Bait Boyd
This is the read that lines up with everything happening around Acosta. To begin with, the show is going out of its way this season to draw a line between Abby’s mental break, Acosta’s current spiral, and Boyd’s grief. The town doesn’t just kill people. On top of that, it convinces people to kill themselves. Or to give up. Or to walk into the dark.
Meanwhile, Boyd had just sat down at that grave and said out loud that he was thinking about not coming back. As a result, the hand showed up immediately. So that’s not a ghost. Rather, that’s the Township answering a prayer it was waiting for him to say. Boyd fighting it off, therefore, is him choosing — for now — to keep going. Which is huge. In other words, he’s not Abby. Not yet.
Theory 3: A Premonition, Not a Visitation
The other angle floating around fan circles, however: it’s a vision of Boyd’s future, not Abby’s past. After all, the show has been playing with non-linear time all season — future Julie is literally walking around — so a premonition of Boyd ending up in that grave is fully on the table. Consequently, the hand might be his own. It might be the town showing him where this road ends.
And if you want to be really cursed about it: the hand wasn’t trying to kill him. On the contrary, it was trying to show him.
But Wait… Are We Doing Zombies Now?
Short answer: no. To begin with, From has never been a zombie show, and it isn’t about to become one in episode 3 of season 4. Instead, the monsters here are something much older and weirder — entities that made a deal for immortality and feed on the people trapped in this place. As a result, a literal walking-corpse Abby would feel cheap, and this show, for all its mess, has earned the right to not be cheap.
What we are probably doing, however: ghosts, manifestations, and the town’s increasingly direct ability to physically interact with the living through the dead. After all, Smiley coming back through Fatima already proved the dead aren’t really dead here. Therefore, the hand is the next escalation of that same idea.
Our Predictions for the Rest of From Season 4
A few things we’re betting on after “Merrily We Go”:
- Sophia gets exposed by Victor before anyone else. First of all, he’s seen the suit. Moreover, he’s the only one with prior memory of what the Man in Yellow does. However, he’s also the easiest to dismiss, which means when he tries to tell people, no one will listen until it’s almost too late.
- The Lake of Tears is where Ethan becomes a real player. After all, “Jim” sent him there for a reason, and From loves giving children information adults aren’t ready for.
- Acosta dies the way Abby did — either by her own hand or Boyd’s — and as a result, he’s finally radicalized into doing something reckless enough to actually crack the town’s pattern.
- Boyd will be back at that grave before the finale. And next time, perhaps, he won’t fight.
- Jade’s reincarnation theory is going to be canon. Notably, the Boy in White getting older is not random. On the contrary, time is moving for him because the cycle is closing.
Final Thoughts (Anghkooey, Bestie)
Merrily We Go isn’t the most plot-heavy episode of From we’ve ever gotten. In fact, some critics are already calling it slow. Even so, we respectfully disagree — this was a vibe episode, and the vibe was the town is winning, and the people in it don’t know it yet. The crows knew. Sophia knows. Furthermore, the thing under Abby’s grave knows.
And Boyd, finally, is starting to know too.
We’ll be back next Sunday with the Episode 4 recap. In the meantime, however, do not, under any circumstances, sit down at a grave in Fromville and start talking.
Anghkooey.
You Might Also Like
Still spiraling about From? Same. Catch up on the rest of our Season 4 coverage:
- From Season 4 Episode 2 Recap: “Fray” Killed Jim — It Didn’t Answer Anything — Our breakdown of the brutal episode that took Jim out and left every survivor with more questions than the barn had blood on the walls.
- From Season 4 Is Back — I’m Hooked, I’m Also Suspicious — The premiere reaction, the early theories, and why this season already feels different from everything that came before it.